When raising capital for a company, issuing shares is a popular practice. Preference shares are one of the more popular choices among all the various forms of shares available and come in two primary varieties – participating and non-participating – which offer different functions and advantages to both shareholders and companies alike. We will examine these further here in this article and delve deeper into their features, benefits, and how they influence a corporation’s finances.
Contents
Before we explore the differences between participating and non-participating, let’s first gain an understanding of what they are. These are a type of securities that offer additional privileges over common shares in terms of dividend payments and liquidation proceeds – providing investors with security and predictability when it comes to returns.
No matter their form or purpose, these shares usually share several similar characteristics:
Fixed Dividend Payments: Preference shareholders typically receive a fixed rate dividend on their shares, usually expressed as a percentage of face value and paid out prior to any dividends being distributed to common shareholders.
Liquidation Priority: Preference shareholders hold priority over common shareholders in any liquidation scenario; they are entitled to receive back their investments before common shareholders receive anything back from their investments.
No Voting Rights: In most instances, preference shareholders do not possess voting rights within a company and thus do not play an active part in decision-making, which typically falls to common shareholders alone.
Now that we understand the fundamental properties of preference shares let’s examine the key differences between participating and non-participating shares.
Participating Preference Shares are an exceptional class of shares that offer their holders additional benefits beyond fixed dividends and liquidation preferences. Participating preference shares “participate” in company profits, giving their owners the potential to profit if the company outshines expectations.
Guaranteed Dividend: As with other these shares, offer a guaranteed fixed dividend payment before any profits are distributed among common shareholders.
Participating in Profits: After receiving their fixed dividend, holders of participating preference shares have an equal stake in any remaining profits of the company, just like common shareholders do, meaning an extra dividend might be issued if profits become substantial.
Higher Risk and Reward: These shares can carry higher levels of risk compared to non-participating, with participating shareholders potentially standing to benefit from any additional profits generated from a company outperforming expectations; however, their returns are not guaranteed beyond any guaranteed dividend payment.
Hybrid Nature: These shares possess an intriguing hybrid quality, combining elements of equity (profit participation) and debt (fixed dividends) into an appealing investment for certain investors. This hybrid nature makes participating preference shares an appealing option.
Align with Company Performance: By investing in these shares, investors align their interests with that of the company when it prospers; when this occurs, all participating shareholders share in its success and reap its benefits.
Attractive for Investors: Preferred shares can be appealing to investors looking for potential high returns from equity ownership without giving up some level of preference.
Flexible Financing Option: Companies may find issuing Participating an effective means of raising capital, as they enable investors to be drawn in by the promise of profit participation without giving away voting control.
Non-participating preference shares provide an easier, less risky investment option compared to their participating counterparts, offering a fixed dividend without participating in company profits and providing less risky but potentially lower returns.
Fixed Dividend: These shares offer shareholders a fixed dividend that does not fluctuate based on company performance, providing consistent and secure income to shareholders.
Non-Participating Shares Do Not Share Profits: Unlike participating preference shares, non-participating shares do not share in any additional company profits beyond their fixed dividend payment. This provides more predictability while potentially limiting returns beyond this fixed income source.
Lower Risk: These shares are considered lower-risk investments when compared with participating preference shares due to their fixed dividend structure, which provides a steady income source and may appeal to more cautious investors.
Limited Exposure to Company Performance: Investors in non-participating preference shares do not directly benefit from an exceptional performance in the company; a fixed dividend rate limits their returns.
Stable Income: Because of the set dividend structure that assures regular payments, non-participating preference shares offer investors with a consistent, predictable source of income.
Lower Risk: These shares tend to be less volatile and offer greater security compared to participating preference shares, making them an excellent option for conservative investors.
Simplicity: Non-participating preference shares offer simplicity when it comes to returns, providing investors with clear expectations regarding dividend payments.
8 Key Differences
| Feature | Participating Preference Shares | Non-Participating Preference Shares |
| Fixed Dividend | Yes, with a fixed rate | Yes, with a fixed rate |
| Participation in Profits | Yes, share in company profits after the fixed dividend | No, do not share in company profits beyond the fixed dividend |
| Potential for Higher Returns | Yes, if the company performs exceptionally well | No, returns are capped at the fixed dividend rate |
| Alignment with Company Performance | Aligned with company success, benefiting from profit growth | Not directly aligned with company performance beyond the fixed dividend |
| Voting Rights | Typically no voting rights | Typically no voting rights |
| Hybrid Nature | Combines elements of equity and debt | Predominantly represents debt-like characteristics |
| Stability of Income | Less stable due to profit-dependent returns | More stable with predictable fixed dividends |
| Simplicity in Returns | Returns can vary based on company performance | Returns are straightforward and constant |
Also Read: How To Make Money This December – 20 Ways
Conclusion
Participating and non-participating preference shares are two distinct classes of shares designed to meet different investor preferences and corporate financing requirements. Participating preference shares offer profit participation at higher risk, while non-participating preference share provide stability through fixed dividends.
Before selecting between these two types of shares, both companies and investors should assess their respective financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment strategies. When raising capital from investors, companies should take note of potential investor preferences; when making investment decisions, they should assess their objectives as well as those of potential investors before selecting which preference share type best matches their portfolios.
Decisions between participating and non-participating must ultimately reflect an assessment of both risk and reward, with both company management and shareholders taking care to understand all implications associated with each option.